Bryan Mills
  • Home
  • Bio and About
  • PowerPoints
  • Papers and text
  • Videos
  • Activities
  • Favourite Things
  • Free Book
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Untitled

What’s wrong with education........

9/25/2011

7 Comments

 
What’s wrong with education.........

As a few people are still speaking to me and using up my time I thought it might be an idea to aim at that most sacred of cows the system known as education.  From my previous blog on the use of ICT you will gather that I don’t necessarily follow fashion in these matters.

Is context helpful?  It usually is.  My experience spans higher education, further education and professional courses, with a little bit of training thrown in.  It crosses across numerous institutions.  Thus the context of this blog is aimed pretty much at all post sixteen education, though as I have a daughter at school I won’t let a lack of direct experience restrict me.  For structural purposes only I’ll start at youngest and lowest level and move forward.

I enjoyed my school days, mostly because no one seemed to push me.  I’m yet to determine if that was a good thing.  Now it seems that there is a constant barrage of tests.  That said there also seems to be a meandering curriculum.   I’m pretty much of the opinion that you need to read, write and count as a starting point and remain fairly shocked by some of what I see emerging at 16.   Teachers seem to work hard but I suspect they are overloaded with top-down initiatives.  Whether it be the Olympics or sustainability, enterprise or culture it seems that there is a reluctance to let teachers just teach the basics in a context that suits them and their students, allowing themes to emerge rather than be forced. 

This translates nicely into the post-sixteen sphere.  Here we are confronted with students who often have poor literacy skills.  Now you might say that literacy isn’t everything; that many have gotten by without it.  The problem is that we are now in the twenty first century where a failure to access and comprehend written material severely limits your engagement and understanding of society and politics.  In fact being able to access this is a basic human right.  So what is the national post 16 reaction to this?  Well it’s impossible to recap all that was missed and still achieve success so people tend to retreat to simpler forms of assessment.  Add in the silver bullet of ICT and we have the perfect answer.  Students can be set reports to write, given clear instructions and guided towards the answers on-line.  Call it all ‘research’ and it actually sounds like something cerebral is occurring – I prefer to call it a typing course.   So now we have a group of students emerging who find it difficult to conduct unguided independent study, who confuse research with following instructions and still have limited ability to construct a rational argument.

Enter the hallowed halls of higher education.  What now?  Well against budget cuts, higher fees, reluctant staff and students as described what can we do?  Traditionally theory was presented, discussed, assignment set and research conducted.  Why is that failing?  Well first presenting theory to individuals who have never had to think independently is destined to be a struggle.  The discussion will then of course also be limited, as will the understanding of an assignment that is not explained in such a detailed way as to leave little to the imagination and as for research, see previous points.  Our response?  Well distance learning jumps in here a little, or at least a hybrid version of it.  Place all the materials on-line so they can dip in and out when required.  Guide them tightly toward the right sources and set tasks based on them (ps – the best bit is it’s cheap).    And as for those that do turn up we have retreated to a version of education I last spotted in Beth’s kindergarten.  We lack inspirational lecturers capable of holding the interest of a class, a class who are less interested than ever.   In order to produce a method that management systems can measure we adopt strange hybrids of exercises, tasks and simulations.  We believe that this somehow links theory to practice, forgetting that no one has ever introduced the theory in anything but the most trivial of ways and that the simulation is as representative of reality as COD is of being on the front line in Afghanistan. 

Do I have solutions or is this just a random rant?  Well I do actually, nice simple ones.  At 16 plus we need to restrict the use of ICT to being one of unguided research only and only ever for a maximum of 25% of the day, preferably less.  As for HE we need to reassert the role of the lecturer, to celebrate it, to give it centre stage if you like.  To love theory and application and translate that love in our delivery.  To celebrate knowledge and understanding. To be passionate.

 

7 Comments
Jason
9/24/2011 10:28:20 pm

Who said "without passion nothing is achieved"

I think thats why i distinctly enjoyed your lectures Bryan as you lecture but you also engage and will allow the student room to branch out while reigning in when needed.

Its also about demeanour and disposition, lecturing or any presentation can seem intimidating and awkward so grasping the audience and feeling confident in what is being delivered is key(My Opinion purely). A tired student or yawning is never a good sign but it does and will happen.

As someone who struggles with memory and remembering, the key things I learnt from study are organisation, time keeping and that human interaction(Or networking being the modern buzz word) are essential. Others face to face inspire me.

Reply
Career Management link
4/18/2012 02:59:59 pm

Education also essential for the success of technology. Also with the help of that persons can manage their career. Admiring the time and energy you put into your website and in depth information you provide.

Reply
Gary
9/26/2011 05:50:41 am

I think from my own experience with H.E. that a main part of the problem is that education has become a business and it is therefore in the institutions interest to give out degrees to their "customers" even when the standard of work of those "customers" is barely equivalent to the old O level. I felt quite frustrated personally that having attended 99% of lectures and worked pretty hard, at the end of my foundation degree I was awarded the same "pass"(missing a distinction by a percentage point) as students who barely attended and had very little understanding of the subject. Similarly with the BSc, you can cruise along with minimum effort and still end up on a low 2:2 or you can work pretty damned hard and get a 2:1 (firsts being particularly difficult because some lecturers seem afraid to go above a certain ceiling in marking) and it doesnt seem that a 2:1 has much more worth on the CV than a 2:2. What this has led to is I think that degrees have lost their worth. If I was an employer looking for a new staff member I would be very wary of putting too much value on someones degree, and very little at all if they only had a 2:2. I do think the internet is a difficult tool to use for research and you can waste an awful lot of time searching for relevant resources. My best work probably came from a mix of internet research and books from the college library. Always looked forward to your lectures though Bryan, made economics interesting and fun :)

Reply
Sarah Davis
10/17/2011 07:51:40 am

Teaching is a voccation not a job. Bryan was my first introduction to Higher Education. The passion for his profession comes out of every pore. With the government self admitting to one in ten boys leaving Primary School with a reading age of ten and this probably being a conservative estimate with many more pupils being little better. Get the reading, writing, maths and a broad eduction encompassing Geography, History and Science in childhood, give all children the chance to reach their full potential. University should be a route into a specific career not some vague dummy qualification given out like sweets. My teenage son is the first cohort to take the new e bacc comprising of two Science subjects, English, Maths, either History or Geography & a modern language with a pass needed in all six areas. They allso get two free options in other subjects. I feel excited. Too many bright children have been allowed to take soft options being lured by specific options like hairdressing, animal care & public services that put all their eggs in one basket. Although these are wonderful choices for children who struggle with academic subjects so many able children are allowed to waste their school years. Although University lecturers should be expected to guide & encourage success they should not have to find ways to bypass failings of schools churning out students with potential & ability that have emerged from an education system having been spoon fed in order for schools to to pander to government targets & not educating our children properly.

Reply
online photography course link
5/15/2012 02:39:08 pm

I was looking for something like this…I found it I am bookmarking this and sharing with my friends on Facebook, twitter and my space. it will help in my study.

Reply
online tutoring jobs link
7/26/2012 10:21:56 pm

I am very much pleased with the contents you have mentioned. I enjoyed every little bit part of it. It contains truly information. I want to thank you for this informative read; I really appreciate sharing this great.

Reply
North Olmsted sex link
10/24/2012 11:51:54 am

Great info, thank you.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Dr Bryan Mills

    "There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. Some kind of high powered mutant never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die" Hunter S Thompson describing the author in 1971.

    Archives

    November 2016
    August 2016
    April 2016
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    October 2013
    August 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011

    Categories

    All
    Strategy

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from vaRiax_, bochalla, playful.geometer, bixentro, Thomas's Pics, alexbuiter, ShanMcG213, EVO GT, DaveBleasdale, Sharon Mollerus, Rob Swystun